Moderator of 1 Session
Presenter of 3 Presentations
PANEL DISCUSSION
HPV VACCINATION TO PREVENT INVASIVE CERVICAL CANCER
DIFFERENTIAL HPV16/18 VACCINE EFFICACY AGAINST HPV31 BY VARIANTS IN THE L1 SEQUENCE UP TO 11-YEARS POST-VACCINATION IN THE COSTA RICA HPV VACCINE TRIAL
Abstract
Introduction
The AS04-adjuvanted human papillomavirus (HPV)-16/18 vaccine (Cervarix®) induces partial cross-protection against phylogenetically-related HPV genotypes, which may be driven by variant-level [e.g., lineage and single nucleotide polymorphism (SNP)] heterogeneity. We examined vaccine efficacy (VE) across cross-protected genotype variants in the Costa Rica HPV Vaccine Trial.
Methods
We included 2846 HPV-vaccinated women (3-doses) and 5465 HPV-unvaccinated women [combined group of hepatitis-A-vaccinated women (3-doses) during the randomized study period (years 1-4) and all women in the screening-only, unvaccinated group during the observational study period (years 4-11)]. The analytical period started two-years post-vaccination (to ensure exclusion of infections present prior to vaccination) through 11-years. Outcomes were HPV31/33/35/45 detection among women HPV-negative for these types prior to the analytical period. Using viral whole genome sequencing, lineages were assigned based on the maximum likelihood tree topology. VEs and VE-ratios were evaluated by lineage and by SNPs in the L1 region.
Results
VE against HPV31 was 76.8% [95% confidence interval (95%CI)=67.5%-84.5%] overall. Compared to VE against HPV31-lineage-A (VE=90.0%; 95%CI=77.3%-98.0%), VE against HPV31-lineage-B (VE=61.6%; 95%CI=26.2%-83.1%) was significantly lower (VE-ratio=0.68; 95%CI=0.29-0.96), while VE against HPV31-lineages-B and-C were similar (VE-ratio=1.22; 95%CI=0.84-2.85) (Table 1). VE against HPV31 significantly differed at nucleotide positions 5921/6238/6367/6372/6772/6796 of L1 (all are lineage-defining positions). One of these SNPs was a nonsynonymous substitution at position 6372, and nucleotide A (defining lineages B/C) had significantly lower VE compared to nucleotide C (defining lineage A) (VE-ratio=0.79; 95%CI=0.65-0.94). Analyses for HPV33/35 were underpowered due to low prevalence of lineage-specific endpoints. VE against HPV45 was 83.0% (95%CI=73.8%-90.4%) overall and was similar between lineages and for L1 SNPs.
Conclusions
Cross-protection afforded by Cervarix against HPV31 may be driven by high VE against lineage-A compared to lower VE against lineages-B/C. An important SNP impacting HPV31 VE may be position 6372, located within the FG loop of L1, established to be important in neutralization.